| Year | Winner |
|---|---|
| 1992 | Nick Johnson |
| 1993 | Nick Kimber |
| 1994 | Andrew Bennett |
| 1995 | Christian Peckham |
| 1996 | Ian Woodward |
| 1997 | Mark Harris |
| 1998 | Toby Gordon-Smith |
| 1999 | Francesca Walker |
| 2000 | Adam Thorp |
| 2001 | Oliver Hall |
| 2002 | Paul Caruana |
| 2003 | Lucy Bricheno |
| 2004 | Gareth Wildig |
| 2005 | Alexander Cannon |
| 2006 | Catherine Marks |
| 2007 | Sarah Watts |
| 2008 | Victoria Yorath |
| 2009 | Matthew Whitwood |
| 2010 | Daniel Graham |
| 2011 | Charles Harrison |
| 2012 | Elizabeth Medcalf |
| 2013 | Jake Carpenter |
| 2014 | Elizabeth Coates |
| 2015 | Maxwell Hammick |
| 2016 | Clare Merivale |
The Felstead Cup was named in honour of the Guild's first President Canon K. W. H. Felstead. This award was given to a member of the Guild for distinction, awarded by the discretion of the Master at the Annual Dinner.
This cup is no longer awarded and in 2017 the Felstead Cup was replaced by the Founders Cup.